Wednesday, February 18, 2015
Ballistic Skill: Do We Need It?
Ok, I keep going back and forth on this, so I'm just going to ask: Do we really need a separate Weapon Skill and Ballistic Skill for each model?
Looking through 3 different editions of 40K rulebooks, I can't find more than a handful of cases where a model's BS and WS differed by more than a single point, and most of those were to give the model a BS or WS of zero to indicate that it couldn't shoot/punch anything. But stuff like this could be handled in the stats and rules of a ranged or melee weapon. No weapon listed of that type, no attack.
On the other hand, it's familiar, and lets us clearly separate a model's ranged and melee abilities in the stat-line and in our balancing equations.
But on the other hand, melee seems to be less important overall in our game than it is in 40K...
Dunno. But I am trying like hell to reduce the number of model stats from 9 to 7, and I dislike the incongruity between "Weapon" and "Ballistic" as qualifiers for "Skill". But I also don't want to change "Weapon Skill" To something like "Melee Skill".
What do you all think?
Andreas Cellarius; Map of the Constellations of the Northern Hemishpere; 1708 SandWyrm here. This week I'm going to put out a series...
Ok, so here's some thinking on when, under the new "I go, you shoot" system, we should test leadership to clear suppression...
Tyranid Hive Ship by Zen Master Rafael Paiva here, and I want to start a little discussion about Space Bugs in this new system.
G. Marchenko. On the outskirt of Stalingrad. I've been asked a question privately about how shooting will work in M42. So here'...
Watchwood has asked that I post some sort of list of design subjects that we'll be discussing and when. Here's a preliminary list...
My alternating Action Phase idea didn't gain any traction, so I'm leaning towards continuing on the classic Movement Phase -> ...
Ryjak's been wanting to talk about grenades, so let's talk.
In a very unfavorable comparison to the US Postal Service, the Royal Mail managed to deliver my large Anvil Industries miniature order (...
A.Mikhailov. Bitter bread Can you feel it? There's a palpable sense of dread befalling 40K these days. A sort of unconscious col...
I'm going to wrap up my thoughts on the galactic setting, as we've already hashed out a lot of the background I'd intended to...