Thursday, February 28, 2013
Infantry, Tanks, & Evasion
Let's break up the relentless rules updates with something that's more fun to talk about. TANKS! Or, at least, one way in which they're going to be quite different from infantry.
The big problem with vehicles in 40K is that there's little differentiation between how they, and infantry, fire. So because of other factors, we get the "Infantry kills tanks, tanks kill infantry" split in 40K. Which we're all familiar with. But... why should it be that way? In real life, the best thing to kill a tank with is another tank. While the best thing to kill infantry with is other infantry.
So how can we make this happen in WarStrike without making big changes to our system?
Easy. We raise the BS and Evasion of Infantry compared to tanks.
Here's some rough numbers to crunch on:
And for those just joining us, here's the comparison chart to figure out what you'd need to hit:
So a battle tank would have a very easy time hitting another battle tank. Since BS 3 vs. Ev 1 would be a 2+ to hit. But it's going to have a very hard time hitting infantry with it's main gun. While infantry will hit tanks easily, but their guns will be a lot weaker. For the static infantry anti-tank guns, their BS would be lower, but a bit higher than a tank's.
Infantry vs. Infantry would work out the same, just with higher stat numbers than we're using now.
Anti-personnel weapons on a tank could get a special rule that doubles their BS. So the machine gun on the front of a battle tank could hit Laansguard in the open on a 4+ or a 5+.
I'm not wedded to these numbers, but they give us a place to start in our discussions.
Andreas Cellarius; Map of the Constellations of the Northern Hemishpere; 1708 SandWyrm here. This week I'm going to put out a series...
Ok, so here's some thinking on when, under the new "I go, you shoot" system, we should test leadership to clear suppression...
Tyranid Hive Ship by Zen Master Rafael Paiva here, and I want to start a little discussion about Space Bugs in this new system.
G. Marchenko. On the outskirt of Stalingrad. I've been asked a question privately about how shooting will work in M42. So here'...
Watchwood has asked that I post some sort of list of design subjects that we'll be discussing and when. Here's a preliminary list...
My alternating Action Phase idea didn't gain any traction, so I'm leaning towards continuing on the classic Movement Phase -> ...
Ryjak's been wanting to talk about grenades, so let's talk.
A.Mikhailov. Bitter bread Can you feel it? There's a palpable sense of dread befalling 40K these days. A sort of unconscious col...
I'm going to wrap up my thoughts on the galactic setting, as we've already hashed out a lot of the background I'd intended to...
G. Korzhev. During the War So we want to make a new 28mm Sci-Fi wargame. Where do we start? Well, I think we start as an artist, with a ...